Skip to content

Diatribe: Giving Table Scraps To Dogs Might Be OK …But Dog Treats Aren’t For Kids.


DogTreatsBack in my horse days, I tried my hand at baking home-made horse treats.  My horse wasn’t a finicky eater, but he was particular when it came to special treats.  He didn’t care for carrots or even slices of apples like other horses in the barn so I found a recipe online and went about the sticky and messy business of baking him special treats.  The horse treat recipe that I used included molasses, oats, flour and carrots that I chopped in a food processor.  I spent an entire evening preparing the strange little brown balls, baking them, and carefully storing the treats in an airtight container that I planned to keep at the barn.

The next evening when I brought the treats to the barn, excited to present one to my horse and certain that he would throw his head back with excitement and beg for more, there was a terrible thunderstorm in the area.  While I was fussing with my horse in his stall, other horses and their owners were scurrying about to be ready for high winds and rain that were quickly approaching.  The barn was sealed tight as the storm engulfed the area while everyone gathered in the center of the barn … me with my container of freshly baked horse treats.

“Looks like we might be here a while.  At least we’ve got something to eat!” – Someone at the barn.

The group joked about my treats, which looked a bit like thick oatmeal cookies that may have been left in the oven for too long, but a few of them asked if they could give one a try.  I shared the treats, explaining the recipe and how I had prepared them, and they nibbled away as they waited for the storm to pass.

Of course, they knew they were eating horse treats and they did so voluntarily.

The same can’t be said about dozens of fourth-grade students at a rural Pennsylvania school who were given pet treats last Thursday and told that they were cookies.  Apparently, a part-time teachers’ aid handed out “treats” to as many as seventy-five students.

“The treats may have been misrepresented as cookies or crackers.  Our research on the product indicates that the treat ingredients would not be harmful to people, with the exception for those individuals with specific food allergies.” – Richard Faidley, Boyerton Area (PA) School District Superintendent.

It remains unclear what may have motivated the aide to give dog treats to the students but students allege that the female aide joked about passing out dog treats and tricked them into eating them for fun for her own amusement.  The recess aide at the Philadelphia-area school has been placed on leave pending the results of an investigation.  I wouldn’t think an investigation would be terribly complicated … did she give the kids dog treats or not?

Surprisingly, I was told, the horse treats that I baked weren’t all that bad.  By the time the storm passed and we all ventured home, the folks in the barn were desperate for something to drink.  I imagine the kids in that Pennsylvania school went home thirsty, too.

My horse wouldn’t eat the treats.  I never made them again.  His only treats from that day on were mints and sugar cubes.


Like this post? Follow the blog and get involved in discussions! Find “Follow via Email” on the right side of the page and click “Follow.”  Click on buttons at the end of each post to share on Facebook, Twitter, Pinterest and other social media sites, too!

Copyright © 2014


From → Diatribes

  1. Rick permalink

    Molasses and Carrots, ugh. I would need to be starving to try those. Did YOU have any…..


  2. Remember when inflation was so high and cat food cost much less than tuna and some folks decided to change their diet? Of course, when I was little I used to love potted meat when on fishing trips and that stuff could pass for dog food.


  3. Every so often Carlos bakes dogs treats made with spinach and tomato and flour. They’re actually pretty good, if a bit dry, but they leave me with a shiny coat.


  4. thedogs'mother permalink

    I had a handsome gelding named Sunny. I remember his feed was full of tasty horsey grains and had molasses poured in and it sure *smelled* good but I was never tempted. 🙂

    It was one of my biggest complaints about school – teachers not understanding medical conditions even through I was really specific. Asthma – you can’t breathe you use a rescue inhaler. Daughter’s first grade teacher told her to wait until the lesson was over before she was allowed to go to the office to save her life. I told her, next time, tell the teacher she was about to throw up and start making gagging noises… Sadly I had many other incidents PE teacher left all 35 backpacks in a gym and then sent a student back to look for daughter’s after the teacher ran the class thru newly mown grass while the mower was still going – this teacher would not allow daughter to carry inhaler.
    Pulled daughter out of PE for the remainder of her school career – had to get all sorts of papers signed, dr. orders, as it was a state requirement for graduation. And had a Long, Forceful Talk with the District Head Nurse.


Please LIKE and Share.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: